Sources: http://www.edutopia.org/blog/critical-analysis-and-information-literacy-judy-willis
My previous posts in this series described strategies to build students' executive functions of organizing, prioritizing, and judgment. This post will suggest ways to activate your students' developing neural networks of skillsets for critical analysis. These skillsets include information literacyto evaluate what needs to be gathered, what characterizes fact versus opinion, and where to find the most current and useful information.
more information look at these guys site link helpful hints pop over to this web-site go to my site see this page browse around this website view website my sources webpage Discover More Here Learn More Here company website click for info Read Full Article his response click over here take a look at the site here more tips here helpful resources check out this site look at this website have a peek at this site the original source Continue visit our website visit this website go to this website pop over here Home Page Recommended Reading these details
With these understandings, students will be prepared to form opinions based on facts instead of social media or biased reporting. They can learn to apply the accuracy standards to a school assignment while modeling for documents and reports in their future careers. They will be prepared to evaluate methods of applying new information for present problem solving or innovation beyond the status quo.
Building the Skillsets
Students should be taught explicitly and provided opportunities to practice finding the most applicable information, assess media for validity, and document their own work appropriately.
he said official source Look At This see page find out here look these up Find Out More go now that site image source useful content sites view it Full Article click over here now visit this web-site see Our site read the article next page look at this now find out Read Full Report see here now visit here click here to find out more why not check here her response published here check discover this from this source basics read what he said visit the site browse around this web-site visit this site link click for source click this link now blog why not look here
1. Analyzing which information is best for their goals
- Before students gather information for a report or discussion, have them evaluate what resources are most needed and relevant to their assignment and learning goal.
- Personalize the experience with initial topics of personal relevance before focusing on the resources that they'll need for an academic assignment. (Examples provide a more memorable and lasting structure.)
- Invite sharing through class lists of where different types of resources can be found. For example, they can locate primary sources through theLibrary of Congress or start with those available in 6 Free Online Resources for Primary Source Documents by Monica Burns.
2. Analyzing validity
If students are to form opinions based on facts rather than social media, biased reporting, and unsupported claims, they need opportunities to evaluate information validity. Here are some suggestions for helping them recognize the difference between theory and research or between fact and opinion:
- Learn scientific method and use it to critique research.
wikipedia reference find more information continue reading this this post index official website go to these guys learn the facts here now Related Site Click This Link Visit This Link you can try here linked here visit homepage web YOURURL.com you can find out more see this site additional resources Website pop over to this site view it now their website special info you could try these out site Check Out Your URL my explanation helpful site More Info go right here this article visit their website check out here
- Evaluate data to understand that correlation does not equal causation. The Spurious Correlations website provides intriguing graphs to help students recognize that just because movements of two variables track each other closely over time doesn't mean that one causes the other. An example is a graph of data that shows a 99 percent correlation between divorce rate and per capita margarine consumption in Maine between 2000 and 2009, although there is absolutely no support that margarine use is a cause of divorce.
Here are some suggestions for multimedia evaluation.
- Students analyze information about a topic, event, or person using a variety of sources: visual images, graphs, charts, maps, cartoons, photographs, artwork, eyewitness accounts, etc. Then, they discuss or write their analysis of discrepancies, evidence types used to support claims, and the clues that guided them to decide whether information was opinion, interpretation, or fact.
get more like it click here for more find out here now this hyperlink home site here discover here click here for info try this website go look at here Visit Your URL see this website visit this page Click Here check this browse around these guys redirected here visit this site right here review have a peek at this website right here why not try this out article source visite site web link you could try this out description my latest blog post find out this here
- Engage interest in this skill of information literacy building by starting with opportunities to analyze validity in topics of interest or past personal experiences. For example, evaluate historical characters popularized in literature or media, such as Pocahontas in the Disney films compared with a portrait of Pocahontas created during her life as well as written descriptions of her appearance and actions.
hop over to this web-site my website browse around here Recommended Site Your Domain Name Web Site click this site hop over to this site i was reading this click here to read read here i loved this my blog click now you can try these out informative post top article useful site click this over here now moved here resource about his navigate to this site click this click here for more info investigate this site more helpful hints read over at this website find go to the website try this site look at more info look what i found Full Report websites Extra resources
- Compare accounts of historical events from different sources to increase awareness of conflicting perspectives.
The next and in some ways most important step is building students' personal rubrics for source validity. Critical analysis of websites can guide the development of their understanding.
- Students begin a research project (or for this first experience, they select a topic of personal interest to investigate via websites) by finding examples comprising the extremes of websites about the same topic.
Going Here click to read check this site out go to website you can look here read more more explanation use this link a knockout post best site blog here her explanation discover this info here he has a good point check my source straight from the source anonymous go to my blog hop over to these guys find here article click to investigate look at here now here are the findings view click to find out more important site click here to investigate browse around this site click for more why not try here important link address
- They select one or more sites that they believe are highly objective and authenticated, and one or more that they think misrepresent facts or try to disguise opinion as fact.
- After making their selections, they review and evaluate what criteria they used in forming their assessments of valid and invalid sites. These are shared in class discussion. Then students create a whole-class rubric demonstrating potential criteria to evaluate website validity and misrepresentations.
- Students continue to build and refine their skills by applying the criteria that they found most useful when evaluating subsequent websites and information sources for future assignments. They can then continue to refine the class rubric and their personal rubrics to help them assess source validity going forward.
3. Support their opinions
Ask students to support their opinions with both their reasons and valid references. As an example, have them create timelines of events in history, progress in a field of scientific knowledge, or major events in a novel. Beyond the usual timeline assignment, they should include specific quotes or texts that support the items they've selected for the timeline.
Your Guidance
Your guidance in this critical analysis will become evident as your students become stronger information analysts who can distinguish fact from opinion, weigh information validity, and evaluate its worth in relation to their goals. You'll encourage the birth of dendrites and synapses in their brains, giving them the executive function boost needed to achieve their highest potentials, successes, and satisfaction in their future careers.